THE QUESTION AT THE HEART OF TÜRKIYE’S AGENDA: TRUST AND ACCOUNTABILITY

Yusuf KANLI

From the opposition’s search for renewal and the investment-fund investigation to HEVBENDÎ, the deaths of workers at HABAŞ and COP31, the week’s debates converged on one question: to whom, and how, must institutions account for their decisions?

As I reviewed both my newly completed, as-yet-unpublished report on media freedom and the news and commentary from 9–16 November that I was preparing to post on one of my social media accounts that morning, I saw how seemingly unrelated stories converged on the same question. Organisational renewal within the opposition, oversight and transparency in the fund investigation, representation in the Kurdish issue, accountability for workers’ deaths, and the implementation of climate commitments—all came down to whether political promises and institutional decisions could inspire trust.

Türkiye’s crisis of trust is about more than declining confidence in the news. It is a broader problem: how far can citizens trust politicians, regulatory bodies, the judiciary, employers or official statements? According to the Reuters Institute’s 2026 Digital News Report, trust in news in Türkiye fell to 28 per cent, while the share of people avoiding news rose to 60 per cent. This points to a weakening of the common ground on which public debate depends.

Renewal must first be tested from within

One of the week’s political debates centred on the congress of a new political formation and the identity it seeks to build. Ruşen Çakır of Medyascope noted that the congress’s references to Atatürk and the CHP risked overshadowing the question of how far the new organisation had developed an identity of its own. A single-candidate contest and a block list also prompted debate over how the movement’s commitment to pluralism was reflected in its internal workings.

This criticism does not mean that a political movement should reject the symbols it has inherited. But a claim to renewal cannot be proved by a new name, a new team or speeches from the podium alone. It also requires competition within the party, representation for differing views and open debate over decisions. Before a political movement can offer pluralism to the country, it must show that dissent and accountability are possible within its own ranks.

Government-aligned commentators offered a different perspective on young people and social change, which also formed part of this debate. Their arguments showed that Türkiye’s politics is not simply a contest between government and opposition; the answers to the question “Where is society heading?” will also shape the country’s political future. Yet understanding social change cannot be separated from making room for change within political organisations themselves.

Oversight matters as much as compensation in the fund crisis

The investment-fund investigation brought the week’s debate over trust into sharpest focus. The payments to investors are certainly important. According to an announcement on 13 November, approximately 161 billion lira had been paid to more than 444,000 investors in 119 funds undergoing liquidation. But compensating investors does not answer how the crisis reached this scale or why oversight mechanisms failed to act sooner.

An interview on Fayn by Ayşe Karabat with economist Erdal Sağlam took the discussion beyond the question of “Who has been arrested?” Who profited? What did the relevant authorities know, and when? Why has the list of beneficiaries not been disclosed? The claims and assessments made in the interview should not be presented as final judicial findings against specific individuals. But answering these questions publicly is essential to restoring confidence in the market.

A credible investigation must ensure that those proven to have committed crimes are held accountable and explain how the oversight chain functioned. Focusing only on individual wrongdoing can leave systemic failures out of view. At the same time, investigating weaknesses in oversight cannot replace individual accountability. Transparency means accountability at both levels.

The question of representation is growing in the Kurdish debate

HEVBENDÎ, which emerged in Diyarbakır, has introduced a new political vocabulary into the Kurdish debate. Its emphasis on collective rights, political status and self-determination differs from a framework centred on disarmament. Without evidence of the alliance’s level of public support, it would be wrong either to describe HEVBENDÎ as representing all Kurdish voters or to dismiss it as an insignificant initiative.

Differences within the new alliance must also be made clear. VEJÎN, which had been named among the founding circles, objected to the founding declaration on 14 November and said it had not joined the formal announcement. This showed that a common political line had yet to take shape. I could not find so far any direct statement by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan or MHP leader Devlet Bahçeli specifically naming HEVBENDÎ. It would also be wrong to infer a particular political position from that silence.

The central issue is whether Türkiye’s new process will address only disarmament or also encompass a wider debate about political representation and rights. Answers given behind closed doors cannot produce lasting public consent. Trust is built when the demands of the communities concerned can be discussed openly and political actors explain, with reasons, what they will and will not accept.

Workers’ deaths and climate pledges face the same test

The deaths of 19 workers at HABAŞ’s facility in Aliağa on 9 November revealed the gravest dimension of the debate over trust and accountability. Evrensel’s report on the union protest outside the factory brought workers’ and unions’ claims about safety conditions into the public debate. Those claims must be tested through an independent investigation. But journalism also has a public duty to follow the inspections, warnings and working conditions, rather than let coverage end with the initial death toll.

News about production and investment often measures success in capacity and scale. Labour reporting asks who bears the cost of that growth. Workplace safety, inspection and a worker’s right to refuse dangerous work are not separate from economic activity; they are among its essential conditions.

COP31 presents a similar test of implementation. Türkiye’s presidency of the summit has brought international visibility, but hosting the event cannot substitute for results in climate policy. The tension between Türkiye’s electrification targets and the absence of a timetable for phasing out coal raises questions about how measurable and binding its commitments are. Emily Rice Johnson’s analysis for Turkey Recap highlights the need for climate finance and adaptation, while Erdal Tanas Karagöl in Yeni Şafak has opened a discussion about the costs of the green transition and energy choices. Both perspectives need to be considered: the transition carries economic costs, but delay also brings social and environmental costs.

Press freedom is a safeguard for an accountable country

What connects all these issues is whether people can find out what is happening and hold decision-makers to account. If journalists face prosecution for their reporting, public institutions do not explain the reasons for their decisions, or the experiences of workers, investors and communities seeking political representation are left out of the news, the problem extends beyond the media sector. Citizens’ right to information and public oversight is also diminished.

The European Commission’s 2026 Türkiye report says that 74 journalists and media workers were arrested, detained or remained in pretrial detention between September 2025 and September 2026. It also addresses broad legal provisions affecting journalism, selective enforcement and economic pressures on media organisations. Independent media and press freedom are therefore not privileges granted to journalists. They are essential to public scrutiny of decisions affecting everything from investment funds and workplace safety to political processes.

The week’s debates in our newly completed report show that Türkiye has no shortage of new political, economic and diplomatic initiatives. The harder task is building the trust that will make them last. That requires transparent oversight, pluralist politics, secure rights and tangible results to support political promises.

The question at the heart of Türkiye’s agenda is no longer simply “What will be done?” Unless there are credible answers to “Who will decide, who will oversee the process and who will be held accountable for the outcome?”, neither claims of renewal nor narratives of success will earn the trust of broad sections of society.

Yayınlanan tüm makale ve yorumların yasal sorumluluğu yazarlarına aittir. Başkent Ankara Strateji Enstitüsü, bu içeriklerden dolayı herhangi bir sorumluluk kabul etmez.
Etiketlendi:

Bu sayfanın içeriğini kopyalayamazsınız